Back to Blog
Science

Beyond the Acronym: Thinking Through Math Order of Operations

Sometimes the rules we're taught in math class can be misleading. We look at a clearer, more intuitive way to tackle order of operations, especially with exponents.

Math and ScienceRogue SchoolersNov 17, 20263 min read0 views

There’s a certain kind of math rule that, when you first encounter it, feels like gospel truth. You learn it, you repeat it, and you trust it implicitly. For many of us, that rule is the Order of Operations—the PEMDAS acronym. It’s the gatekeeper for algebra, the supposed key to conquering physics and chemistry.

But what happens when the rule itself is… flawed? What if the very structure we use to guide our thinking is leading us down an incorrect path?

As we guide our children through the wonderful, messy, and sometimes baffling journey of learning, we often encounter these moments where the "right way" isn't the *only* way, or perhaps even the *best* way. This video tackles just that: the Order of Operations, and why relying too heavily on a simple acronym can actually cause more confusion than clarity.

Understanding the Rules (and When to Question Them)

The core concept—that math requires a set of consistent rules—is sound. We need structure, whether we're planning a homeschool co-op schedule, designing a curriculum unit, or solving for 'x'. But this lesson dives into the nuances, particularly when exponents get involved, and how the established mnemonic (PEMDAS) can trick the student into thinking multiplication always beats division.

The presenter does a wonderful job of breaking down the hierarchy: Parentheses first, then Exponents. But here’s the crucial takeaway for any parent guiding their student through math:

  • Multiplication and Division are Equals: They sit at the same priority level.
  • Addition and Subtraction are Equals: They also sit at the same priority level.

Instead of thinking of them as a strict sequence (M before D, A before S), the guidance here is to read them like a book—left to right. This shift in perspective is powerful. It moves the student from rote memorization to true conceptual understanding.

A Shift in Perspective for Your Math Curriculum

If you're teaching math curriculum—whether you're following a structured approach like Charlotte Mason or exploring more hands-on methods—this video offers a fantastic "Aha!" moment for any student who has struggled with these types of problems. It’s a gentle reminder that in learning, sometimes the most reliable tool isn't the catchy acronym, but the deep, flexible understanding of *why* the rule works.

For our homeschool families, this means we can encourage critical thinking not just in our history curriculum or language arts, but right down to the arithmetic. It’s about teaching our kids to question the "why" behind the "what."

If you're looking for ways to make math feel less like a rigid set of rules and more like an exploration, remember that real-world problem-solving often requires that same flexible thinking. Whether you're planning a nature study field trip or just tackling the week's math worksheet, questioning the assumptions is where the real learning happens.

Don't let a single acronym dictate the boundaries of your family's learning journey. Keep asking those "but what if?" questions!

Need to deepen your family's learning experience this week? If you're ready to apply this critical thinking to a whole subject area, consider signing up for a Field Trip to see how these concepts play out in a real-world setting, or maybe take a look at claiming a Faculty profile to connect with a mentor who specializes in conceptual math understanding!

Frequently Asked Questions

The main issue is that PEMDAS can incorrectly suggest that multiplication must always come before division, or that addition must come before subtraction, when in reality, they are at the same priority level.

Instead of rigid rules, the presenter suggests looking for parentheses first, then exponents, and then performing multiplication/division and addition/subtraction strictly from left to right, like reading a book.

The principles discussed apply to calculations involving exponents, but the core lesson is about developing flexible, conceptual thinking rather than just memorizing a formula.

Loading comments...

Related Posts

Simplifying Math: Finding the Whole Truth in Numbers
Techniques
Simplifying Math: Finding the Whole Truth in Numbers

Sometimes the biggest concepts, like simplifying square roots, can be broken down into manageable, understandable steps.

The Math Sorcerer
The Math Sorcerer
Rogue Schoolers
4 min
0 0 0about 1 month ago
Beyond the Textbook: Finding Wisdom in Word Problems (And Keeping Faith in Learning)
Techniques
Beyond the Textbook: Finding Wisdom in Word Problems (And Keeping Faith in Learning)

Sometimes the best lessons aren't found in the chapter headings, but in the simple word problems that make us think differently.

TabletClass Math
TabletClass Math
Rogue Schoolers
4 min
0 0 0about 2 months ago
Making Sense of Fractions: A Practical Approach to Math Concepts
Techniques
Making Sense of Fractions: A Practical Approach to Math Concepts

Fractions can feel abstract, but understanding the relationship between mixed and improper fractions is much simpler when you visualize what they truly represent.

Math and Science
Math and Science
Rogue Schoolers
3 min
0 0 0about 2 months ago