Hearing the Call: Navigating Deep Theological Waters as Disciples

Brother, sister, friend. Have you ever found yourself deep in theological waters—the kind where the conversation moves from simple testimony to intricate doctrine, where the questions are layered like the stained glass of a cathedral? It can feel overwhelming, can't it?

As we gather here in the Rogue Disciples community, we are constantly being called to do the work—to be Internet missionaries, to share the Gospel in the quiet moments between our appointments. Sometimes, the most valuable preparation comes not from reviewing our own notes, but from hearing how others wrestle with the foundational beliefs of other faiths. It’s a reminder that being a disciple means being ready to learn, to listen, and to answer with the Spirit-guided love of Christ, no matter the topic.

Recently, I came across a discussion featuring Dr. Scott Hahn and Cameron Bertuzzi discussing conversion, Catholicism, and the Papacy. While the subject matter is far outside the doctrines we study in our usual Book Clubs or Bible Study Groups, what struck me wasn't the theology itself, but the *spirit* of the exchange. It was a masterclass in thoughtful engagement.

When you are preparing for missionary discussions, or even just having a casual chat with someone new, you might encounter topics that seem utterly foreign to the restored gospel. How do you respond? Do you get defensive? Do you shut down? Or do you remember that our goal is always to point back to the Savior?

It’s easy to get caught up in the details—the *primacy*, the *infallibility*, the historical succession. These are weighty topics! But remember the core principle we live by: Every member can be a disciple anywhere, all the time. Whether you are in a formal setting, or just having a coffee with a friend who has deep roots in another tradition, you are representing the restored gospel of Jesus Christ.

This reminds me of something we talk about in our informal study sessions. It’s not always about having the perfect answer; sometimes, it’s about having the perfect posture. It’s about humility, curiosity, and a deep, abiding love for the Savior.

A Bite-Sized Mission Prep Skill: The Art of Gentle Inquiry

If you’re feeling the pressure of missionary preparation, try this: When faced with a complex doctrinal question you aren't immediately equipped to answer—especially one that involves history or institutional structure—do not panic. Instead, pivot back to the core of the gospel. You can say something like, “That’s a really deep and fascinating area of study. What I find most central to my understanding, and what I hope you’ll find valuable too, is the Atonement of Jesus Christ. It’s the bedrock of everything, isn’t it?”

This gently redirects the conversation from an external system to the eternal plan of salvation, which is always our strongest ground. It shows knowledge, but it prioritizes the message.

These discussions, whether they are about the Papacy or the plan of salvation, teach us that the Spirit is our ultimate guide. We don't need to be experts in every field; we need to be disciples of Christ.

If you want to practice these skills, I highly recommend diving into the social scripture study layer within LivingBook. Sometimes seeing how others have highlighted or commented on scripture related to covenants or divine authority can give you fresh perspectives. It’s a wonderful, low-stakes way to sharpen your skills!

For those of you who are feeling the pull to deepen your study, I’ve bookmarked a few excellent resources. If you’re looking for deeper dives into foundational doctrine, check out some of the recent Iron Rod authors available in LivingBook. It’s a wonderful way to keep the wheels turning!

If you haven't been to a gathering recently, I’d love to see you at our next virtual meet-up! It’s a chance to share experiences, pray together, and just lift each other up as we continue this sacred work together.

Keep striving to be Christlike in every conversation, no matter how challenging the topic!