Back to Blog
Stories

Navigating the Question of Evil: A Disciple's Perspective on Genesis 3

When the world isn't perfect, how do we understand the problem of evil? We'll look at some philosophical ideas and anchor ourselves in the gospel.

BibleTalk.tvRogue DisciplesAug 7, 20264 min read0 views

Brothers and sisters, if you’ve ever spent time in the field—or even just studying scriptures alone in your study—you know that the gospel is meant to give us answers that are both profound and deeply comforting. We learn about a perfect world, a world where everything was "very good." But then, we look around us. We see pain, we see loss, we see struggle, and we see the undeniable evidence of brokenness.

It's a question that has stumped the greatest minds throughout history, and it’s one that even the most seasoned missionary discussions can't fully satisfy in a single sitting. How could evil enter a perfect creation? If God is omnipotent and good, why does suffering exist?

It’s natural to feel overwhelmed by these deep theological questions. We’ve heard theories—from dualism, which suggests good and evil are two eternal, battling forces, to existentialism, which suggests we create our own morality. These ideas, while intellectually stimulating, often leave us feeling adrift, like we’re trying to navigate by starlight when we need a compass pointing directly to Zion.

The material we reviewed from Genesis 3 really sets the stage. We see the contrast between the pristine perfection of Eden and the reality of the fallen world. The temptation is to get lost in the philosophy—to get bogged down in 'what if' scenarios that distract us from the central truth: the Atonement of Jesus Christ.

This is where our discipleship, our commitment to the work, has to pull us back to the source. We aren't meant to be philosophers debating abstract concepts; we are disciples learning how to bear testimony of a living Redeemer. The scriptures, particularly the narrative arc leading to the Fall, point us not toward an unsolvable equation, but toward a divine plan of restoration.

Anchoring Our Minds in the Gospel

When we encounter these tough questions—whether it's in a missionary discussion, a Book Club, or even just scrolling through the social scripture study feed in LivingBook—our first instinct should be to remember the pattern of revelation. The gospel doesn't just *tell* us God is good; it *shows* us how He restores goodness through Christ.

If you’re feeling the weight of these big questions, remember that the best way to approach them is not by trying to build a perfect theory, but by inviting the Spirit to teach you. I encourage you to use our resources. If you’re wrestling with how to answer a tough question from an investigator, don't try to wing it. Bring it to Davee. He’s trained in the AI Investigator role, and he can walk you through structuring an answer that is both doctrinally sound and Spirit-filled.

Remember, we are called to be Internet missionaries, disciples anywhere, all the time. This means that whether you are in a formal setting or just having a quiet moment with your scriptures, you have the power to share the truth. Don't let the complexity of the world distract you from the simplicity of the gospel message: Jesus Christ lives, and He overcame death.

A Little Prep Skill for Our Next Gatherings

As we continue to build our testimonies, let's focus on one small skill this week: **The 'Bridge' Statement.** When someone presents a philosophical idea that contradicts the gospel (like dualism), don't just refute it. Acknowledge the *intent* behind their question, and then build a bridge back to Christ. For example: "I understand why you find the idea of two opposing forces compelling, because it gives a clear picture of conflict. In our understanding, though, conflict is real, but the ultimate victor isn't a force—it's the Atonement."

If you want to practice this, join our next virtual gathering! It’s a low-pressure environment perfect for refining these skills. Check the link in the sidebar for details on the next Disciple Challenge.

Frequently Asked Questions

Dualism is a philosophy that suggests good and evil are two separate, eternal, and opposing forces locked in a constant battle for domination.

The gospel directs us away from purely philosophical answers and toward the truth found in the Atonement of Jesus Christ as the ultimate resolution to brokenness.

We can practice using the 'Bridge' Statement technique, which involves acknowledging the questioner's point before guiding the conversation back to the gospel truth.

Loading comments...

Related Posts

Remembering the Source: Divine Order in Creation and Our Lives
Science
Remembering the Source: Divine Order in Creation and Our Lives

As we study the foundational accounts of Genesis, we are reminded that God establishes order—a pattern we can apply to our own discipleship.

BibleTalk.tv
BibleTalk.tv
Rogue Disciples
3 min
0 0 027 days ago
From 'In the Beginning' to Our Covenant: Seeing the Grand Scope of Genesis
Stories
From 'In the Beginning' to Our Covenant: Seeing the Grand Scope of Genesis

Genesis isn't just a story of creation; it’s the foundational narrative of the Plan of Salvation, showing us where everything—including our discipleship—began.

BYU Religious Education
BYU Religious Education
Rogue Disciples
3 min
0 0 04 days ago
Seeing the Whole Tapestry: Agency, Honor, and the Spirit in Genesis
Stories
Seeing the Whole Tapestry: Agency, Honor, and the Spirit in Genesis

Sometimes the most challenging narratives in scripture teach us the deepest lessons about agency and divine purpose.

Scripture Central
Scripture Central
Rogue Disciples
3 min
0 0 08 days ago