The Echoes of Socialism: A Latter-day Saint Perspective

The current political climate, marked by a renewed interest in socialist ideologies, has sparked a fascinating and potentially unsettling conversation within our community. It’s a conversation that demands more than a cursory glance; it requires the diligent application of scriptural principles and the wisdom of past leaders. Recent attention, particularly in the Salt Lake Tribune and amplified by Greg Matsen’s podcast, has brought this historical reality to the forefront, and it's a reality we must understand.

Matthew Bowman's article and the subsequent discussion in Greg Matsen’s podcast—listen to the full episode—highlight a surprising truth: socialism has a history within the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. This isn’t a new revelation, but the current context compels us to re-evaluate its significance. The echo of socialist rhetoric, now emanating from younger generations and even appearing in political campaigns within Utah, seems to be resonating with a familiarity that demands scrutiny.

The podcast rightly points out that simply acknowledging this historical precedent doesn't automatically legitimize contemporary claims. As John Salido and John McCormick remind us, the Socialist Party of America once commanded significant support, even capturing nearly a million votes in 1912. Yet, the embrace of socialist principles then—and now—must be tempered by the unwavering counsel of the Brethren. Marion G. Romney’s 1966 conference address, which Matsen highlights, offers a crucial corrective. It wasn't a condemnation of all economic cooperation, but a firm rejection of a system that fundamentally undermines individual agency and the divinely ordained principles of stewardship.

The distinction is vital. The United Order, a foundational principle in early Latter-day Saint settlements, wasn't socialism. It was a system built on voluntary contribution, individual responsibility, and the unwavering pursuit of righteousness. It arose from a spirit of unity and mutual support, guided by the principles found in Doctrine and Covenants 51 and other revelations. True socialism, as often understood today, seeks to supplant individual initiative with centralized control, a concept that stands in stark contrast to the inherent value placed on personal responsibility in our doctrine.

The podcast’s insight regarding the fall of the Iron Curtain’s influence on the Church’s stance against socialism is important, but not the whole story. The warnings from Ezra Taft Benson and others in the 80s weren't solely a reaction to the Cold War; they were a consistent reaffirmation of timeless principles. Isaiah's prophecies regarding the dangers of unchecked power and the importance of righteous governance (Isaiah 2:13-22) serve as a perpetual warning against any ideology that prioritizes collective control over individual liberty and divine guidance.

We, as Latter-day Saints, are called to be discerning. We are taught to “seek ye diligently and teach one another, and ponder the words of the prophets, and consider them well” (D&C 50:19). This requires more than a superficial understanding of political labels. It demands a deep, abiding commitment to the principles of the Restoration and a willingness to confront uncomfortable truths.

The resurgence of socialist sentiment is not merely a political phenomenon; it's a spiritual challenge. It's a test of our commitment to the covenant and our ability to discern truth from error. Let us, therefore, approach this discussion with humility, seeking the guidance of the Spirit and the wisdom of the prophets.

What principles from the Book of Mormon or Doctrine and Covenants best address the dangers of unchecked power and the importance of individual responsibility?